Romeo and Juliet in the Coal Region

LuckyLeprechaunBlogTour Welcome to The British Are Coming, Y’all! Today through Sunday 20 March are lucky days for you. My blog is participating in the “Lucky Leprechaun Giveaway Hop” along with more than 250 other blogs listed at the end of this post. All blogs in the hop are offering a book related giveaway, and we’re all linked, so you can easily hop from one giveaway to another. To find out how to qualify for the giveaway on this blog, read through today’s Relevant History post below and follow the directions. Then hop to another blog. Enjoy!

 

JRLindermuthAuthorPhoto Relevant History welcomes author J. R.Lindermuth, a retired newspaper editor. Lindermuth was born and raised in Pennsylvania’s anthracite coal region. He’s the author of eight novels, and his stories and articles have been published in a variety of magazines, both print and on line. He writes a weekly historical column for two area newspapers and is librarian of his county historical society, where he assists patrons with genealogy and research.  For more information, check his web site.

***

JRLindermuthBookCover My historical suspense novel Watch The Hour focuses on the conflict between mine owners and their employees — particularly the Irish — in the 1870s, in Pennsylvania’s anthracite coal region. My research corroborated the fact that prejudice never goes away, though the identity of the victims may change over time. Race and religion aren’t always the qualifying factors. Mere difference is enough to warrant suspicion.

More than a million Irish refugees flocked to the United States between 1846 and 1855. They worked whatever jobs they could find and were routinely exploited. Many found their way to Pennsylvania’s anthracite coal region, where they encountered some of the worst exploitation and hatred. Most of the management and skilled labor positions were held by the English and Welsh — old enemies.

In the 1870s, an expanding economic depression pitted mine owners and their laborers, particularly the Irish, in conflict over wages and working conditions. The situation spawned a wave of violence. The Irish and the Molly Maguires, a secret organization linked to them, soon became a scapegoat for those in authority.

Private police forces were commissioned by the state but paid by the coal companies, sworn to protect property of the mine owners. The miners believed their real purpose was to spy upon targeted agitators and intimidate and break up strikers.

The subject of the Molly Maguires is still controversial today, with many refusing to believe the organization existed or that its members were guilty of the crimes of which they were accused. Others believe they operated secretly and used the Ancient Order of Hibernians, a legitimate benevolent organization, as a front. Probably more atrocities attributed to the Mollies than occurred. But the organization’s existence is documented, and people do have a tendency to strike back at oppression.

The largest owner of coal lands was the Philadelphia and Reading Railroad, headed by Franklin B. Gowen. The P&R was a monopoly controlling the rail lines and the coal fields, and it was Gowen’s goal to control the workforce as well. The miners formed a union, the Workingmen’s Benevolent Association (WBA), and Gowen was determined to wipe it out.

Gowen’s opportunity came when a strike led to sabotage and then the murder of ten mine bosses. Gowen accused the WBA of harboring terrorists — the Molly Maguires. He manipulated the press to convince the public that most of the Irish were Mollies and responsible for the murders and sabotage.

The end result was a series of trials, which resulted in the conviction of forty-one people and the hanging of twenty miners. The WBA was crushed, and it was a long time before another union improved mine working conditions. At this late date it’s difficult to separate legitimate from false accusations.

I grew up hearing stories about those days from my grandfather and other older residents who had the stories passed down to them. Of the twenty men hanged, four were from my home area. Peter McManus was hanged in 1879 for the murder of Frederick Hesser. Patrick Hester, Patrick Tully and Peter McHugh were hanged in 1878 for the murder ten years earlier of Alexander Rea, a mine superintendent.

Hester, Tully and McHugh were brought to trial solely on the accusation of Daniel Kelly, an alcoholic known familiarly as Kelly the Bum. While jailed in Pottsville, Schuylkill County, Kelly confessed to his own involvement in Rea’s murder and turned state’s evidence on the other three in return for immunity.

Despite protests of innocence, the three were convicted and sentenced to hang on March 25, 1878 at Bloomsburg, Columbia County. The records testify the only ones who behaved properly that day were the Irishmen who accepted their fate calmly and with dignity, not even flinching when three pine coffins were dumped unceremoniously at the foot of the gallows as the nooses were being placed round the men’s necks.

The crowd that gathered to witness the hangings was reported as uncommonly large and unruly. A newspaper account said Sheriff John W. Hoffman was so drunk he was barely able to stand when he pulled the rope on Hester. A dozen spectators clambered onto the roof of a nearby chicken shed to watch, and it collapsed under their weight, smothering to death thirteen-year-old Sunny Williams. Farmer Joseph Engst became drunk and fell from the roof of the Exchange Hotel, crushing his skull. The boisterous crowd upset the buggy of William Yiengst, injuring his wife.

And, to top it off, someone stole Hester’s wedding ring before his body was stiff. The ring was later returned by Abby Engle, a railroader, who apologized that he’d been “carried away by the emotion of the day.”

Into this milieu in Watch the Hour, I introduce a young coal company police officer named Ben Yeager, a decent fellow who does his best to follow orders while trying to be fair to the workers whose lot he sees as little different from his own. Despite his efforts at fairness, his job makes him the enemy of the Irish. I complicate matters by having him fall in love with an Irish lass, Jennie. Like a certain young couple from Verona, these lovers must vie not just with family differences, but also with the society in which they dwell. And Ben faces the additional problem of being pressured by the mine owner to marry his granddaughter, who is also in love with the youth. For their love, Ben and Jennie risk the enmity of family and friends, their religion, their jobs, and their very lives.

Coal mining remains a tough and dangerous occupation. In contrast, the Irish are, for the most part, accepted and valued members of society in the United States today. But the prejudice they endured still exists and can be seen in the plight of other ethnic groups in the land.

***

A big thanks to J. R. Lindermuth. He’ll give away a print copy of Watch the Hour to someone who contributes a legitimate comment on my blog this week. I'll choose one winner from among those who comment by Sunday at 6 p.m. ET. Delivery is available within the U.S. only.



Comments

Romeo and Juliet in the Coal Region — 42 Comments

  1. I truly enjoyed this article and thanks for sharing. I am so glad to read some one realizes how dangerous coal mining can be. We are not far from several mines and you have to see them to know what each worker gives. Thanks for writing this book and this article. susan Leech

  2. Susan, thanks for stopping by. Every year, a coal mining accident somewhere makes big news. After story details emerge, it seems that little changes in the industry from year to year. The issues and hazards are always the same, as is the grief on the faces of survivors.

  3. This looks like a great book. Coal mining IS a tremendously dangerous job, with not enough compensation. My husband’s mentor left WV and coal mining when his dog froze to death under the bed he and his wife were sleeping in.

  4. This looks like a very interesting read! It sounds as though it captures everything I enjoy reading…a little mystery, a little good v. evil and of course a little love story!
    Thanks for the giveaway, I look forward to reading more on your blog.
    Cici
    cicistheories[at]gmail[.]com

  5. Miners may be paid more today, but the dangers are a constant. Most of my ancestors worked on the railroad, but my great-grandfather, Henry Francis Fisher, lost three brothers to mining accidents and he was once trapped with four other men for 12 hours by a cave in.

  6. Susanna, if you enjoy reading about the lesser-known aspects of history, I encourage you to check my blog each week for the latest Relevant History post. We can learn so much from what material is strategically omitted from our high-school history textbooks. You’ll find some of those facts in Relevant History. Thanks for your comment!

  7. Holly, thanks for stopping by. Re: the necessity of coal mining, yes, we’ve recently received another reminder of how little we truly know about harnessing fission as an energy source, so coal mining will continue to be in the picture, a necessary link in the chain of viable energy sources for humankind.

  8. I first learned about the Molly Maguires from Sherlock Holmes in

      The Valley of Fear
      . And then there was the film with Sean Connery and Richard Harris – the latter focusing on the conflicted emotions of the undercover Pinkerton detective. A shameful episode from America’s capitalistic past.
  9. Suzanne, in my great-grandfather’s time the only breathing device they had was the human lung. Air-paks didn’t come until after his mining days. For light they used carbide lanterns on their helmets.
    During the cave-in I mentioned, Henry passed the time playing quoits with the youngest member of their crew, a 17-year-old, to keep his spirits up.

  10. John, what a chilling fictionalization this story would make. Those five guys were trapped below the earth’s surface with only the air that had been caught with them. Under such circumstances, carbide lanterns wouldn’t have done a whole lot to dispel the notion that the men had been entombed.
    I know how absolutely black it can get underground. Back in the early 80s, I took a tour of Jewel Cave, in the Black Hills of South Dakota. After the elevator had taken us down several hundred feet to a platform, and the tour guide had sent back up to the surface three people who’d decided they were too claustrophobic to continue the tour, the guide asked us to grab hold of the hand rail so he could demonstrate what it was like for cavers and miners who lost the light from their lamps.
    The sensation of absolute darkness, with my retinas struggling to find a light source and not succeeding, was eerie, disorienting. It’s something I’ve never forgotten.

  11. Bill, the Molly Maguires have been villified as terrorists. Some of their acts must be accepted in that light. Still, with the rail barons fighting every effort to unionize, the miners had few legal options to fight oppression.
    Suzanne, there’s a tourist operation called Pioneer Tunnel in Ashland PA at which people are taken 800 feet underground in a former mine to show what it was like. One of the things they do is extinguish all light to demonstrate the same experience you had. Very disorienting.

  12. These big blog gives are a lot of fun, aren’t they? No need to enter me, Suzanne (unfortunately. I mean, hello? I still have YOUR books to read!).
    I’m dropping in to let you know I’ve cleared your comment through moderation at West of Mars, so come on by again and help get the first Weekend Hangout swinging!

  13. the Molly Maguires have been villified as terrorists. Some of their acts must be accepted in that light.
    Okay, John, I’ll play Devil’s Advocate. Some of the acts of Patriots during the Revolutionary War qualified as acts of terrorism. It all comes down to who wrote the history, doesn’t it? LOL

  14. Sounds like a very interesting book. The historically based ones are a favorite of mine.

  15. I must confess–Sean Connery introduced me to the Molly Maguires, but the stories have fascinated me ever since. There’s a lot in your post I didn’t know. I’m sure your book is excellent. I’d like to read it.

  16. Thank you for bringing information regarding coal mining to light. The men who risk their lives everyday are not given the credit they deserve.

  17. Nice to see you here, Ellis. You’ve pointed out one cool aspect of this Relevant History feature. It informs folks about history that didn’t make it into their high school history texts. Fun history.

  18. The men who risk their lives everyday are not given the credit they deserve.
    Nicole, you’re so right. If they’re named in the news, it’s usually because they’ve died in an accident. Even then, they may not be named.

  19. You’re definitely right, Suzanne. Some might call the acts of the Patriots terrorism–just as was the case with the Mollies. When people are oppressed, sometimes there is no other recourse than what we call terrorism.

  20. I am a new fan of historical fiction, and I just love that I can get lost in another time and place. I have a friend that is from England and I could listen to him talk for hours, and thus I imagine his voice narrating British words to me, lol;) Thanks for the chance to win!

  21. I just love that I can get lost in another time and place
    Karen, welcome to another time and place. There are plenty of British accents where I write. :-)

  22. Thanks for joining me, John, and writing such an interesting Relevant History essay. But don’t run off just yet. We aren’t finished. Today’s the final day of the Lucky Leprechaun Giveaway Hop.

  23. My paternal grandmother came over here from Calais,
    France with her parents so her dad could make a living in the coal mines! My dad will be turning 93 and has told us many stories about how his dad and brothers worked in the mines…His
    mom would take in laundry
    to help make ends meet!
    They called the area where they mined “Dunk’s Row.”
    I am the proud owner of the tiny oil burning lights they wore on their mining hats. I would love to read John’s book.
    Many thanks, Cindi